AI shifts effort from doing work to overseeing it
As generative AI takes on more of the production of work, our papers explore the tensions this creates for the people who remain responsible for it. Our review of decades of automation research argues that this repeats an old irony, because automation makes human oversight more important even as it takes over the work. In our survey of 319 knowledge workers, people welcomed the effort AI saved them in gathering information and drafting, yet described new work in verifying, integrating, and steering what it made. In that paper, we suggest that stewardship fits this role better than teammate or collaborator, because the person remains accountable for work the AI produced. In our study of 15 spreadsheet users, people valued the chatbot as a partner for thinking, one calling it a rubber duck that talks back, yet found verifying its answers burdensome.
Strongest evidence
- Review: productivity loss with AI. Our review argues that generative AI repeats the ironies of automation, because checking output people did not create is demanding without the situational awareness that producing it would have given them.
- Survey: critical thinking at work. Knowledge workers said AI saved effort in gathering information, solving problems, and drafting. They described new effort in verifying information, integrating AI responses, and steering the AI while staying accountable, which we call task stewardship.
Also points this way
- Participatory prompting: AI-assisted data analysis. Spreadsheet users valued the chatbot as a partner for thinking, yet found verifying its answers burdensome.